The 49ers Defense Won Saturday, and Shanahan Is Coaching the Preseason Opener
The defense got the better of Brock Purdy on Saturday, Kyle Shanahan watched it happen from behind a pair of sunglasses, and he's the one running the sideline when Tennessee comes to Levi's on Thursday.
The defense won Saturday. Not a series, not a red zone period that somebody spins into a headline afterward, the day. Brock Purdy didn't have it, and the group on the other side of the ball is the reason why, and after the last few Augusts around here that sentence is worth typing slowly.
Understand why this fan base is allergic to camp takes. Every August somebody on defense makes a play, three hundred people report it as a breakthrough, and then the season starts and the same unit gets run at for two hundred yards on the ground by a team that told everybody exactly what it was going to do. We've been burned by the August version of this defense enough times to know that one good Saturday isn't a season. Fine. Noted.
It still matters, and here's the honest reason. Practice is a closed system. There's exactly one quarterback in this building who knows the offense the way the man who designed it knows it, and beating him is the hardest thing the defense gets to do all week. When Purdy is off, it's usually because somebody made him off. Coverage held long enough that the read went to the second and third option. Pressure showed up before the timing did. That's what a defense winning a day actually looks like, and it doesn't happen by accident against this offense.
The other half of it's the part nobody should skip past. Purdy having a rough Saturday in the second week of August isn't a crisis, it's Tuesday. He isn't playing Tennessee for anything on Thursday, he isn't playing the Rams for anything until September, and the quarterback who spent three years turning seventh-round into a passer-rating argument is allowed to throw a bad ball in shorts. Anyone building a panic column off it in August is doing the thing this site exists to complain about.
Then there's Shanahan, standing there in sunglasses, watching his own offense get handled and giving away nothing, which is the most Shanahan detail imaginable. The sunglasses are half the man's public personality at this point. You can't read him. You never could. He has watched his offense get shut down in far more expensive settings than a Saturday practice and worn the same expression.
The news underneath the sunglasses is the part with a date attached. He's coaching the preseason opener. Kyle Shanahan, on the sideline, running the game against Tennessee at Levi's on Thursday night. Preseason openers are usually where a head coach delegates, stands with his arms folded, and lets the staff run the thing while he watches the roster fight for the last eight spots. Not this one.
You can read that two ways and both are probably a little true. The generous read is that there's enough new on this roster, and the depth chart page has the full picture of how much, that he wants his hands on the operation from the first snap rather than the first week of September. The less generous read is that August has been August around here, the injury list isn't the sentence you want attached to the second week of camp, and a coach who has been through what this coach has been through doesn't hand the wheel to anybody in a year that has to go right.
Either way, Thursday is now worth actually watching, which isn't something you get to say about most preseason openers. The head coach is running it. The defense just spent Saturday proving it can win a day against the best quarterback it'll see in practice all year. Those two facts arriving in the same week is the first genuinely encouraging thing this camp has produced.
Keep the expectations where they belong. The season starts in Melbourne on 10 September and nothing that happens in a Levi's preseason game changes the shape of it. The rest of the year is laid out in the season schedule hub, the structural read is in the season preview, and everything else lives on the 49ers hub. But for one Saturday in August, the defense was the story for the right reason, and the head coach is treating Thursday like it counts. Take it.
More coverage: Bay Area Sports section · Bay Area Sports · Bay Area Sports Blog home