A's at the All-Star Break: 41-55, a Nine-Game Skid, and the Mirage I Warned You About
They led the AL West earlier this year. They limp into the break at 41-55, fourth place, eight games back, losers of nine straight. I said the hot start was a house of cards. Here is the full first-half accounting, and no, I am not going to be gracious about it.
Where the A's actually stand
Here is the number, and it is a beautiful one if you have been reading this blog all year: 41-55. That is where the Athletics sit at the All-Star break, fourth place in the AL West, eight games behind the Rangers, and they got there by losing nine games in a row on the way to the intermission. This is a team that was in first place in the division earlier this season, that had a whole segment of the internet writing the plucky-little-A's fairy tale, and it has spent the last few weeks disintegrating on national television. Fourteen games under .500 at the break. From the penthouse to the basement, and the elevator only went one direction.
I have said the same thing about this team since May, so I am not going to suddenly develop manners at the midpoint. The hot start was the aberration. This is the correction. When you strip out the early-season luck, 41-55 is a lot closer to who the Athletics actually are than that first-place mirage ever was, and the standings have finally caught up to what the underlying baseball was screaming the whole time.
The first half, honestly
Give the devil his due first: the start was real fun to watch if you were an A's fan, and it was real annoying if, like me, you could see the math underneath it. They jumped out to a lead in the West on the back of a record that was running well ahead of the run differential, winning close games, catching breaks, riding a couple of hot stretches. Every honest look at the profile said the same thing. The pitching was not this good. The record was borrowed. And borrowed records get repossessed.
The repossession has been brutal. Over the ugliest ten-game stretch of the collapse the A's went 1-9, hit .213 as a team, ran a 7.09 ERA, and got outscored by nearly 40 runs. That is not a slump. That is a team coming apart at every seam at once, the exact way I said it would go when the regression finally arrived. The signature of the whole thing was the pitching, precisely where I told you it would break. A staff putting up touchdown numbers on the scoreboard night after night is not a staff getting unlucky. It is a staff that was never as good as three months of standings pretended, and now everyone can see it.
The offense has not bailed anybody out either. A .213 team average across the skid is not one guy in a funk, it is the entire order going cold at the same time, pressing, chasing, and playing from behind because the pitching keeps digging a five-run hole by the third inning. Not even Brent Rooker's bat can drag a lineup out of that. And it all came with illness ripping through the clubhouse and bodies missing, which is a real thing, but it is also exactly the kind of excuse a sinking franchise uses to convince itself the water is temporary. It is not temporary. This is the level.
The Sacramento of it all
And let's not forget the backdrop to this entire circus, because it is the part that makes the collapse so perfect. This is a team playing its home games in a minor-league park in Sacramento, in limbo, stripped of its city, marketed as a feel-good story while it hunts for a permanent home somewhere else entirely. The first-place run gave everybody a reason to look past all of that. The nine-game skid took the reason away. What is left is a displaced franchise, 14 games under .500, playing out a lost season in a borrowed ballpark. Bay Area villains to the end, and now not even good ones.
The second half: it gets worse
So where does this go? You did not come here for a hedge, so I will not give you one. I think they keep losing. The schedule does not care that they are hurting, the pitching does not fix itself over a four-day break, and a team that just went 1-9 and looked this lifeless does not flip a switch because the calendar wants a fresh start. The habits of a losing team are set in now, the body language is set in, and when it gets like this it tends to get worse before it gets better.
The only real second-half story worth watching is a sell-off. A 41-55 club with pending free agents and a July 31 deadline looming has one intelligent move, and it is to trade anything with value to a contender and admit what the last few weeks proved. Whether this front office is honest enough to do that, on a franchise already allergic to spending money, is its own question. But there is no version of the next three months where this roster contends. The mirage broke in the desert heat, right on schedule, and the smart money says the losing is not close to done.
Mark it down at the break. First place to fourth, 41-55, nine straight into the intermission. I called it a house of cards when everyone told me to relax. The cards came down. And until something fundamental changes about this roster and this rootless franchise, I would not bet a nickel on the second half being any kinder than the first.
More A's: I Told You the A's Were a Mirage · The A's Play in Sacramento Now · A's section · Columns