The Giants Blew Another One, and It Is the Same Sickening Story

Two outs from a win over the worst team in baseball, the bullpen handed it back. Rockies 4, Giants 3. If you aren't furious yet, you haven't been paying attention.

I am so tired of writing this column. Not the writing part. The living-through-it part. For the thousandth time this season the San Francisco Giants took a lead into the late innings, handed the ball to their bullpen, and watched the whole thing burn to the ground. Tuesday night it was the Rockies, the worst team in baseball, a franchise that has been road kill for months, and the Giants still found a way to lose to them 4-3 at Oracle Park. Two outs, that's all they needed. They couldn't get two outs. And if you've followed this team for more than a week, you already knew exactly how it was going to end the second the phone rang in that bullpen.

Here's the crime scene. The Giants led 2-1 heading to the ninth. All they had to do was close out three outs against a Colorado lineup that has spent the season getting no-hit, blown out and embarrassed. Instead they went and got Caleb Kilian, and Kilian did what this bullpen does. Mickey Moniak singled to start it. Then a walk to Troy Johnston. Then a bunt single from Jake McCarthy to load the bases, because of course the Giants couldn't field a bunt either. Kyle Karros ripped a two-run single to center to flip the lead. Cole Carrigg tacked on a sacrifice fly. Three runs, three hits, and Kilian didn't record a single out before they finally went and got him. The bases were empty when the inning started and full of Rockies by the time anyone in that dugout reacted.

Three runs, no outs. Sit with that. This is a man they trusted with a one-run lead against the worst offense in the sport, and he couldn't retire one hitter. The Giants scratched a run back in the bottom of the ninth on a Rafael Devers sacrifice fly, which only makes it worse, because it means they were one competent inning of relief away from winning this game and didn't get it. Antonio Senzatela, who came in at 8-1, gets the win he did nothing to earn. Juan Mejia slams the door for his fourth save. And the Giants trudge off having lost a game they had in their pocket to a team that has no business beating anybody.

So let me say the part I've been circling for weeks. Tony Vitello has no idea how to manage a bullpen, and I'm done pretending otherwise. This isn't a one-night thing. This is a pattern, night after night, the same fingerprints on every one of these losses. You don't get to the ninth inning with a lead against the Rockies and lose it because the baseball gods are cruel. You lose it because the person filling out the card keeps putting arms into spots they can't handle, keeps waiting one batter too long to make a move, keeps treating high-leverage innings like they're interchangeable when everyone watching can see they aren't. Vitello was a college coach eight months ago and it shows every time the game tightens up. The players aren't good enough, fine, but a manager is supposed to squeeze every out he can out of what he has, and instead he leaves guys out there to bleed. He gets outmanaged in the ninth inning by the Colorado Rockies. Read that again.

And no, I'm not letting Buster Posey off the hook, because the deeper insult here's the roster he built. Posey looked at this bullpen in the offseason, looked at a group with not one single trustworthy leverage arm, and decided that was fine. He decided the Giants could sleepwalk through a full season without a real closer, without a setup man you'd bet a dollar on, without one reliever you actually want on the mound with the game on the line. That isn't bad luck. That's a plan, an actual decision made by an actual person, and it was insane the day he made it. You can't compete without leverage arms. Everyone in baseball knows this. Everyone except, apparently, the man running the Giants, who was supposed to be the adult in the room and instead handed his manager a bullpen made of tissue paper and asked him to protect leads with it.

The result is what we watched again tonight, and what we've watched all year. Good starts wasted. Leads that mean nothing because nobody can hold them. A team that could actually be a few games more respectable if it had even a league-average bullpen, sitting instead in the basement of the standings, losing to the Rockies of all teams, in the most predictable way imaginable. The blown saves aren't flukes anymore. They're the identity of this franchise. This is who the 2026 Giants are: a team that finds the lead, then gives it back, then makes you feel stupid for having hoped.

And that's the part that's really getting old. The hope. Every few days they do something, a young pitcher looks good, a kid splashes one into the Cove, and you let yourself think maybe, maybe this is the night it's different. Then the ninth inning comes and the bullpen door swings open and it's the same horror movie with the same ending. It's exhausting. It's embarrassing. It's a joke of a year, and I'm not going to dress it up as anything else. Losing to the worst team in baseball because your closer can't get an out and your manager can't manage and your front office never bothered to build a bullpen isn't a rough patch. It's a season-long indictment of everyone in charge.

I'll be back here tomorrow, and probably the day after, writing some version of this same column, because nothing about how this team is run tells me it's going to change. But I'm not going to keep pretending it's anything other than what it is. This is a sickening, horrifying, deeply disappointing year, and the people responsible have names. Tony Vitello can't manage this bullpen. Buster Posey never gave him a bullpen worth managing. And the Giants keep losing games they already won. Same old story. It's getting old. And somebody at 24 Willie Mays Plaza needs to be held to account for it, because the fans sitting through this deserve a whole lot better than what they're getting.

More coverage: Giants section · Bay Area MLB · Columns · Bay Area Sports Blog home