Thirty-Five Years, One Final, and No Stanley Cup: The San Jose Sharks History

An expansion team in a building in Daly City, one of the worst seasons in league history, two decades of playoff hockey, a Presidents' Trophy, one Final, and still nothing in the case.

On the Bay Area championship ledger, every championship this region has won, twenty-one of them across six franchises, there's one line with a zero on it, and this is the page that explains it. It isn't a story about a bad franchise. That's what makes it hurt.

Where they came from. The NHL awarded San Jose an expansion team for 1991 to Gordon and George Gund, who had previously owned the California Seals, so Bay Area hockey came back to a region that had already lost a team once. The first two seasons were played at the Cow Palace in Daly City, which isn't San Jose and wasn't new in 1991, while the arena downtown was built.

The beginning was genuinely terrible. The 1992-93 season produced one of the worst records in the history of the National Hockey League. Then in 1993-94 they moved into the new building, made the playoffs for the first time, and knocked out a Detroit team that was supposed to win the whole thing. Two years, from historic embarrassment to the biggest upset of the postseason. It was the first sign that this franchise was going to do everything the difficult way.

The long good era, which is the actual tragedy. From 2004 to 2019 the Sharks made the playoffs in all but one season, and the complete playoff history is its own page. That's a fifteen-year run of relevance that most franchises never have. They won a Presidents' Trophy in 2009 for the best record in the league and lost in the first round. They reached back-to-back Western Conference Finals in 2010 and 2011. Joe Thornton and Patrick Marleau played most of their careers here and are two of the better players of their generation, and neither of them ever lifted a Cup in teal.

2016, the one time it was actually there. The Sharks reached the Stanley Cup Final for the only time in franchise history and lost to Pittsburgh in six games. Not swept, not embarrassed, beaten by a better team in a series that was closer than the scoreline. It's the high-water mark and it's now a decade old.

2019, the greatest thing that ever happened in that building. Game 7 against Vegas, the Sharks four goals down in the third period, a five-minute major called, and then five goals in barely four minutes on the same power play. SAP Center has never been louder and probably never will be. They won it in overtime, went to the Conference Final, lost, and then the franchise fell off a cliff for six years. That's a fairly complete summary of what it's like to support this team.

Then the collapse. Six straight seasons out of the playoffs, ending with back-to-back finishes at the bottom of the league. Thornton and Marleau left. The building emptied out. In a region that had the Warriors winning championships and the Giants and 49ers taking up all the oxygen, a bad hockey team in San Jose became genuinely invisible, which is how a market with a real hockey audience ended up with almost nobody paying attention.

Why they've never won, honestly. There's no curse and there's no single villain. There's a long stretch of very good regular-season teams that ran into either a hotter goaltender or a deeper opponent, a 2016 team that got to the last round and met a Pittsburgh side at its peak, and a front office that kept the window open a year or two longer than it should have. Being consistently good and never great is a specific kind of failure and this franchise is the league's clearest example of it.

Where it stands now. Better than it has in years. Last season produced 86 points and a 34-point improvement, one of the biggest year-over-year jumps in club history, and it still wasn't enough for a playoff spot, seven straight years out now. But there's a twenty-year-old centre who just broke Thornton's franchise scoring record and signed the largest contract in the sport, and that's a different kind of starting point than the last rebuild had. Macklin Celebrini is the reference page on him and the depth chart is what's around him.

What it would mean. The A's are leaving, the Raiders are gone, the Warriors moved across the bay and the Giants are rebuilding. San Jose has held onto its team for thirty-five years without ever threatening to move it and without ever winning anything. A Stanley Cup in that building would be the single best sports story this region could produce, precisely because nobody outside of it's expecting one. The season hub tracks the attempt.

The rest of our coverage is on the Sharks hub, and the regional context is on the Bay Area championship ledger and the franchise relocations page.

More coverage: Bay Area Sports section · Bay Area Sports · Bay Area Sports Blog home